Suggestions by @cowboi

Scarlett Johansson

as @Plazynoodles in Homestuck

Owen Wilson

as Sweet Bro in Homestuck

Jim Carrey

as Jack Noir in Homestuck

Joe Jonas

as The Signless in Homestuck

Jared Leto

as Doc Scratch in Homestuck

Dascha Polanco

as The Handmaid in Homestuck

Kanye West

as White King in Homestuck

Natasha Lyonne

as MOM Roxy in Homestuck

Margo Martindale

as NANNA Jane in Homestuck

Samira Wiley

as Vriska Serket in Homestuck

Shannon Purser

as Jane Crocker in Homestuck

Janelle Monáe

as MOM Rose in Homestuck

Aubrey Plaza

as GRANDMA Jade in Homestuck

Jared Leto

as Kurloz Makara in Homestuck

Taylor Lautner

as Jake English in Homestuck

Archie Panjabi

as Porrim Maryam in Homestuck

Matt Watson From Supermega

as Eridan Ampora in Homestuck

Ben Stiller

as BRO Dirk in Homestuck

Brandon Routh

as Equius Zahhak in Homestuck

Dylan Sprouse

as Dirk Strider in Homestuck