Suggestions by @cooperdean

Grace Van Dien

as Holly Reddick in The Preacher's Daughter

Score: +1

Louis Hofmann

as Willoughby Tucker in The Preacher's Daughter

Score: +1

Taylor Russell

as Janie in The Preacher's Daughter

Score: +1

Drew Starkey

as Isaiah Abram in The Preacher's Daughter

Score: +1

Tandi Wright

as Vera Cain in The Preacher's Daughter

Score: +1

Hunter Schafer

as Ethel Cain in The Preacher's Daughter

Score: +1