Suggestions by @coolguy

Matt Jones

as Scrad / Charlie in Men in Black Trilogy (2007-2022)

Score: +2

Jack O'Connell

as Joker in Every Batman Character

Score: -6

Alexander Skarsgård

as Joker in Every Batman Character

Score: -5

George MacKay

as Joker in Every Batman Character

Score: -6

Alfred Molina

as Dr. Ivo Robotnik in The Sonic the Hedgehog Duology (2010 - 2012)

Score: +24

Keith David

as Knuckles the Echidna in The Sonic the Hedgehog Duology (2010 - 2012)

Score: +9

Peter Stormare

as Steppenwolf in Lars von Trier's DCEU

Score: +3

Patricia Clarkson

as Martha Kent in Lars von Trier's DCEU

Score: +2

Paul Bettany

as Ocean Master in Lars von Trier's DCEU

Score: +3

Nicole Kidman

as Atlanta in Lars von Trier's DCEU

Score: +3

Bryce Dallas Howard

as Mera in Lars von Trier's DCEU

Score: +3

Riley Keough

as Harley Quinn in Lars von Trier's DCEU

Score: +2

Kirsten Dunst

as Lois Lane in Lars von Trier's DCEU

Score: +3

Jamie Bell

as The Flash in Lars von Trier's DCEU

Score: +2

Michael Fassbender

as Joker in Every Batman Character

Score: -7

Tom Hiddleston

as Guildenstern in Rosencrantz & Guildenstern Are Dead (2010)

Score: +1

Dan Stevens

as Guildenstern in Rosencrantz & Guildenstern Are Dead (2010)

Score: +1

Bill Nighy

as Abbé Faria in The Count of Monte Cristo (2022)

Score: +8

Simon Pegg

as Laurence Laurentz in Hail, Caesar! (2022)

Score: +3

Jodie Foster

as C.C. Calhoun in Hail, Caesar! (2022)

Score: +3