Suggestions by @computeyd

Jack Nicholson

as William Afton in Freddy's: A FNaF Series (1983-1987)

Score: +1

Robert Englund

as William Afton in Freddy's: A FNaF Series (1983-1987)

Score: +1

Willem Dafoe

as William Afton in Freddy's: A FNaF Series (1983-1987)

Score: -1

Margot Kidder

as Lacy Hardt in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: +1

John Goodman

as Horatio Bruno in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: +1

Vanessa Redgrave

as Elsa Bastion in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: +1

Gena Rowlands

as Elsa Bastion in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: +1

Roger Moore

as Sedgewick Sable in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: +1

Lee Grant

as Mitzi May in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: +1

Gena Rowlands

as Mitzi May in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: +1

Faye Dunaway

as Mitzi May in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: +1

Shirley MacLaine

as Mitzi May in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: +1

Roy Scheider

as Sedgewick Sable in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: +1

Richard Roundtree

as Nicodeme Savoy in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: +1

Richard Pryor

as Nicodeme Savoy in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: +1

Morgan Freeman

as Nicodeme Savoy in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: +1

Garrett Morris

as Nicodeme Savoy in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: +1

Roy Scheider

as Dorian Zibowski in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: +1

Warren Beatty

as Sedgewick Sable in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: -1

George Segal

as Sedgewick Sable in Lackadaisy (1976-1980) Live Action TV Series

Score: +1