Suggestions by @computeyd

Josh Hutcherson

as Mike Schmidt in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: +1

Michael J. Fox

as Mike Schmidt in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: +1

James Stewart

as Scott Kowalski in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: -1

Montgomery Clift

as Scott Kowalski in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: -1

Sam Shepard

as Scott Kowalski in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: +1

Bill Pullman

as Scott Kowalski in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: -1

Casey Affleck

as Scott Kowalski in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: -1

Bradley Whitford

as Scott Kowalski in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: -1

David Morse

as Scott Kowalski in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: +1

Kyle MacLachlan

as Scott Kowalski in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: +1

Martin Sheen

as Scott Kowalski in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: -1

Ilan Mitchell-Smith

as Scott Kowalski in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: -1

Guy Madison

as Scott Kowalski in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: -1

William Petersen

as Scott Kowalski in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: +1

Harvey Keitel

as Scott Kowalski in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: -1

Paul Newman

as Scott Kowalski in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: -1

Robert De Niro

as Scott Kowalski in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: -1

Roy Scheider

as Scott Kowalski in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: +1

Warren Beatty

as Edwin Murray in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: +1

Peter Capaldi

as Edwin Murray in Hurricane, Utah(story private)

Score: +1