Suggestions by @coachdallas

Tom Welling

as Superman in The Ultimate Showdown of Ultimate Destiny

Score: +1

Justin Bieber

as Aaron Carter in The Ultimate Showdown of Ultimate Destiny

Score: +1

Nicole De Boer

as Star Trek in Hottest Actress by Franchise

Score: +3

Gabriel Macht

as President Thomas J. Whitmore in Independence Day (2006)

Score: +1

Alexandra Park

as Leia Organa in Star Wars (2021-2025)

Score: -14

J.K. Simmons

as J. J. Jamison in Spider-Man (1992)

Score: +1

Rob Schneider

as Marty Gilbert in Independence Day (2006)

Score: +1

Juliet Landau

as First Lady Marilyn Whitmore in Independence Day (2006)

Score: +2

Pauley Perrette

as Tiffani in Independence Day (2006)

Score: +1

Jerry Stiller

as Julius Levinson in Independence Day (2006)

Score: +1

Chris Hemsworth

as Major Mitchell in Independence Day (2006)

Score: +1

Mischa Barton

as Alicia Casse in Independence Day (2006)

Score: +1

Wilmer Valderrama

as Miguel Casse in Independence Day (2006)

Score: +1

John Cena

as Marine Captain Jimmy Wilder in Independence Day (2006)

Score: +1

Megan Good

as Jasmine Dubrow in Independence Day (2006)

Score: +1

Michael B. Jordan

as Captain Steven Hiller in Independence Day (2006)

Score: -1

Tim Allen

as Russell Casse in Independence Day (2006)

Score: +1

Samuel L. Jackson

as Dr. Brackish Okun in Independence Day (2006)

Score: +1

James Marsters

as David Levinson in Independence Day (2006)

Score: +1

Robert Picardo

as Albert Nimzicki in Independence Day (2006)

Score: +1