Suggestions by @cicalabast

India Eisley

as Drusilla Blackthorn in Lord of Shadows

Score: -2

Claire Holt

as Camille Belcourt in The Infernal Devices (trilogy)

Score: +18

Kaya Scodelario

as Cecily Herondale in The Infernal Devices (trilogy)

Score: 0

Ashley Greene

as Sophie Collins in The Infernal Devices (trilogy)

Score: -5

Jake Abel

as Nathaniel “Nate” Gray in The Infernal Devices (trilogy)

Score: +6

Max Irons

as Gideon Lightwood in The Infernal Devices (trilogy)

Score: +14

Jannis Niewöhner

as Gabriel Lightwood in The Infernal Devices (trilogy)

Score: -2

Eddie Redmayne

as Henry Branwell in The Infernal Devices (trilogy)

Score: +18

Jenna Coleman

as Charlotte Branwell in The Infernal Devices (trilogy)

Score: +34

Dianna Agron

as Jessamine Lovelace in The Infernal Devices (trilogy)

Score: -18

Mitch Hewer

as James “Jem” Carstairs in The Infernal Devices (trilogy)

Score: -26

Gavin Leatherwood

as James “Jem” Carstairs in The Infernal Devices (trilogy)

Score: -16

Joshua Anthony Brand

as William “Will” Herondale in The Infernal Devices (trilogy)

Score: +3

Adelaide Kane

as Theresa “Tessa” Gray in The Infernal Devices (trilogy)

Score: -9

Àstrid Bergès-Frisbey

as Theresa “Tessa” Gray in The Infernal Devices (trilogy)

Score: +34

Daniele Rampello

as Jaime Rosales in Lord of Shadows

Score: +2

Rob Raco

as Kieran in Lord of Shadows

Score: -1

Xavier Serrano

as Diego Rosales in Lord of Shadows

Score: +2

Jamie Campbell Bower

as Jace Herondale in Lord of Shadows

Score: +14

Emanuela de Paula

as Diana Wrayburn in Lord of Shadows

Score: -1