Suggestions by @ciaramariehaskell

Adrian Lyles

as Christian Joseph in Never 'Til Now

Leah Kate

as Elizabeth Stevens in Never 'Til Now

Tanner Buchanan

as Elliott Hartley in Never 'Til Now

Lexa Doig

as Margot Quinn in Never 'Til Now

Joe Keery

as Garrett Keene in Never 'Til Now

Sabrina Carpenter

as Penelope Quinn in Never 'Til Now

Shemar Moore

as Robert Joseph in Never 'Til Now

Julie Bowen

as Faye Murphy in Never 'Til Now

Griffin Santopietro

as Denny Quinn in Never 'Til Now

Bailee Madison

as Abigail Quinn in Never 'Til Now

Timothée Chalamet

as Regulas Black in Harry Potter Recast

Teo Briones

as Data in The Goonies