Suggestions by @chickwitahat

Shelley Hennig

as Dylan O'Brien in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Zoey Deutch

as Dylan O'Brien in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Lili Reinhart

as Dylan O'Brien in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Dakota Johnson

as Dylan O'Brien in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Josephine Langford

as Dylan O'Brien in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Naomi Scott

as Dylan O'Brien in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Victoria Pedretti

as Dylan O'Brien in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Florence Pugh

as Dylan O'Brien in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Victoria Justice

as Dylan O'Brien in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Kaya Scodelario

as Dylan O'Brien in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Holland Roden

as Dylan O'Brien in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Selena Gomez

as Dylan O'Brien in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Hailee Steinfeld

as Dylan O'Brien in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Alexandra Daddario

as Dylan O'Brien in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Matthew Daddario

as Victoria Justice in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Pierson Fodé

as Victoria Justice in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Casey Deidrick

as Victoria Justice in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Victoria Justice

as Zac Efron in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Taron Egerton

as Victoria Justice in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Michael B. Jordan

as Victoria Justice in Actors who should play love interests to other actors