Suggestions by @chickwitahat

Andrew Garfield

as Katherine McNamara in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Ryan Potter

as Mia Healey in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Caleb McLaughlin

as Mia Healey in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

KJ Apa

as Mia Healey in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Joe Keery

as Mia Healey in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Logan Lerman

as Mia Healey in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Victoria Justice

as Mia Healey in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Sabrina Carpenter

as Mia Healey in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Zendaya Coleman

as Mia Healey in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Timothée Chalamet

as Mia Healey in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Peyton List

as Mia Healey in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Madelaine Petsch

as Mia Healey in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Liam Hemsworth

as Mia Healey in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Ansel Elgort

as Mia Healey in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Cole Sprouse

as Mia Healey in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Tom Holland

as Mia Healey in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Dylan O'Brien

as Mia Healey in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Dylan O'Brien

as Katherine McNamara in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Tom Holland

as Katherine McNamara in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Ansel Elgort

as Katherine McNamara in Actors who should play love interests to other actors