Suggestions by @cherrybomchelle

Willem Dafoe

as Fitz in From Below

Joel Edgerton

as Harland in From Below

Taika Waititi

as Devereaux in From Below

Tom Holland

as Aiden in From Below

Margot Robbie

as Hestie in From Below

Amar Chadha-Patel

as Roy in From Below

Chris Evans

as Sean in From Below

Gwendoline Christie

as Vanna in From Below

Shushila Takao

as Cove in From Below

Jared Leto

as Edgar in The Carrow Haunt

Harrison Ford

as Jones in The Carrow Haunt

Isabella Sermon

as April in The Carrow Haunt

Lin Shaye

as Marjorie in The Carrow Haunt

Katie McGrath

as Lucille in The Carrow Haunt

Michael Sheen

as Piers in The Carrow Haunt

Oliver Jackson-Cohen

as Mark in The Carrow Haunt

Romesh Ranganathan

as Taj in The Carrow Haunt

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Bernard in The Carrow Haunt

Alexandra Daddario

as Remy in The Carrow Haunt