Suggestions by @charredsoup

Chris Hemsworth

as Jonathan Joestar in JoJo's Bizzare Adventure: Phantom Blood (Netflix)

Score: +1

Bobby Lockwood

as Jonathan Joestar in JoJo's Bizzare Adventure: Phantom Blood (Netflix)

Score: +1

Rachel Weisz

as Miss Pauling in Team Fortress 2 Live Action Film

Score: +1

Nathan Vetterlein

as Jeremy in Team Fortress 2 Live Action Film

Score: 0

Jason Statham

as Mr. Mundy in Team Fortress 2 Live Action Film

Score: 0

Willem Dafoe

as The G-Man in Half-Life

Score: -1