Suggestions by @charlesp

Chris Hemsworth

as Chris McLean in Total Drama Island

Score: +4

Patrick Dempsey

as Chris McLean in Total Drama Island

Score: -2

Liam Neeson

as Winston Wolf in PULP FICTION (2020s)

Score: +4

Sean Penn

as Winston Wolf in PULP FICTION (2020s)

Score: +5

Matt Dillon

as Adult Stanley Uris in Stephen King's It Duology (1997-1999)

Score: +2

Ron Perlman

as Oscar Bowers in Stephen King's It Duology (1997-1999)

Score: 0

Jared Harris

as Delbert Grady in Overlook Hotel

Score: +1

Amanda Seyfried

as Winnifred "Wendy" Torrance in Overlook Hotel

Score: +1

Vincent D'Onofrio

as Delbert Grady in The Shining

Score: +1

Timothy Hutton

as The Haunting of Hill House in Face Claims Sorted by Netflix Shows and Movies

Score: +2

McCabe Slye

as Tommy Slater in Fear Street Part Two: 1978

Score: +2

Bruce Campbell

as Quentin Beck/Mysterio in Spider-Man Trilogy (1997-2001)

Score: +3

Dan Aykroyd

as Jerry Langford in The King of Comedy (2020)

Score: 0

Dan Aykroyd

as Jerry Langford in The King of Comedy (Remake)

Score: +1

Anthony Hopkins

as Delbert Grady in The Shining (2000)

Score: 0

Sydney Sweeney

as Susan Norton in Salem's Lot

Score: -3

Willem Dafoe

as Professor John Montague in The Haunting of Hill House

Score: 0