Suggestions by @castlesforlorn

Matthew Lillard

as Daniel Kingsley in Spider-Man The Next One (Hobgoblin)

Score: +1

Matthew Lillard

as Roderick Kingsley in Spider-Man The Next One (Hobgoblin)

Score: +1

Jon Bernthal

as Tony Bancarella in All Saw

Score: +1

Al Pacino

as Tony Bancarella in All Saw

Score: +1

Josh Groban

as Vincentio Mortimer in Castles Forlorn

Score: +1

Dev Patel

as Fletcher Hiraeth in Curse of Strahd

Score: +1

Laura Benanti

as Emma Carew in Jekyll & Hyde The Musical

Score: +1

Robert Cuccioli

as Sir Danvers Carew in Jekyll & Hyde The Musical

Score: +1

Tom Hiddleston

as Simon Stride in Jekyll & Hyde The Musical

Score: +1

Pedro Pascal

as John Utterson in Jekyll & Hyde The Musical

Score: 0

Oscar Isaac

as Henry Jekyll in Jekyll & Hyde The Musical

Score: +1

Dan Stevens

as Henry Jekyll in Jekyll & Hyde The Musical

Score: +1

Glenn Howerton

as Henry Jekyll in Jekyll & Hyde The Musical

Score: +1

Ioan Gruffudd

as Henry Jekyll in Jekyll & Hyde The Musical

Score: +2

Bella Ramsey

as Hildegard Perot in Castles Forlorn

Score: +1

Lee Pace

as Count Strahd Von Zarovich in Curse of Strahd

Score: +3

Anthony Stewart Head

as Rudolph Van Richten in Curse of Strahd

Score: +1

David Dastmalchian

as Johann Samorrow in Curse of Strahd

Score: +1

Robert Cuccioli

as Henry Jekyll in Curse of Strahd

Score: +1

Bruce Wayne

as February 19 in Fictional Characters by Birthday

Score: +3