Suggestions by @castingsinmyblood

Thomas O'Malley

as Jamie Foxx in What if this actor played

Crimson Dynamo

as Oleg Taktarov in What if this actor played

Jake Gittes

as Adrien Brody in What if this actor played

Ulysses S. Grant

as Jason Clarke in What if this actor played

Royce (Predators)

as John Cassavetes in What if this actor played

Lord Moritsugu Katsumoto

as Ken Takakura in What if this actor played

Khan Noonien Singh

as Sendhil Ramamurthy in What if this actor played

Lex Luthor

as Miguel Ferrer in What if this actor played

The Punisher (Frank Castle)

as Stephen Lang in What if this actor played

Bilbo Baggins

as David Tomlinson in What if this actor played

General Sam Lane

as Donald Moffat in What if this actor played

Conquest (Invincible)

as Clancy Brown in What if this actor played

Grendel's Mother

as Salma Hayek in What if this actor played

Gillian B. Loeb (Batman)

as Paul Giamatti in What if this actor played

Samyaza (Noah (2014))

as Candy Candido in What if this actor played

Puppet Master (Marvel)

as Brad Dourif in What if this actor played

Victor Frankenstein

as Robert Pattinson in What if this actor played

Silas Stone

as Ernie Hudson in What if this actor played

Uncle Chuck

as Joe Morton in What if this actor played

Mongul

as Joel Edgerton in What if this actor played