Suggestions by @casting666
264 suggestions
Sarah Michelle Gellar
as Joyce Summers in Sunnydale Season 3
Neil Patrick Harris
as Mr. Trick in Sunnydale Season 3
Colby Minifie
as The Deputy Mayor in Sunnydale Season 3
RuPaul
as The Mayor in Sunnydale Season 3
Brenton Thwaites
as Wesley Wyndam-Pryce in Sunnydale Season 3
Amber Midthunder
as Faith Lehane in Sunnydale Season 3
Camila Mendes
as Cordelia Charisma Chase in Sunnydale Season 3
Hunter Schafer
as Danielle “Oz” Osbourne in Sunnydale Season 3
Nicholas Galitzine
as Angel in Sunnydale Season 3
James Marsters
as Rupert Giles in Sunnydale Season 3
Booboo Stewart
as Xander Harris in Sunnydale Season 3
Amandla Stenberg
as Willow Rosenberg in Sunnydale Season 3
Sydney Sweeney
as Buffy Anne Summers in Sunnydale Season 3
Ty Burrell
as Ted Buchanan in Sunnydale Season 2
Jamila Velazquez
as Ampata in Sunnydale Season 2
Billie Lourd
as Chanterelle in Sunnydale Season 2
Archie Panjabi
as Ethel Rayne in Sunnydale Season 2
Rob Mac
as Willy 'Emerald' The Snitch in Sunnydale Season 2
Gus Kenworthy
as Larry Blaisdell in Sunnydale Season 2
Rico Rodriguez
as Jonathan Levenson in Sunnydale Season 2