Suggestions by @castielovers01
116 suggestions
Wendy Kilbourne
as Karen Smith in Mean Girls (1984)
Karen Valentine
as 60s' in Which Actress Should've Played Heidi in Various Decades?
Blair Underwood
as Chad in Fear Street: Prom Queen (1985 My Version)
Heidi Mueller
as 2000's in Which Actresses Should've Played Sidney Prescott in Various Decades?
Lori Spengler
as Lori in Sorting Characters by Name
Lisa Schrage
as Lauren Hannon in Black Christmas (1986)
Dianne Kay
as Chlöe Rice in 13 Reasons Why (70s)
Tiffany (H2O: Just Add Water)
as Tiffany in Sorting Characters by Name
Milo Ventimiglia
as Michael Blaire in Fraternity Row (Sorority Row 2004 Genderswap)
Krista Tesreau
as Chlöe Rice in 13 Reasons Why (80s)
Teri Ann Linn
as 80s' in Which Actresses Should've Played Pam Miller in Various Decades?
Alice (Regal Academy)
as Alice in Sorting Characters by Name
Tiffany Brissette
as Young Agnes in Black Christmas (1986)
Eleven (Stranger Things)
as Raised in a Lab in Characters Sorted by TV Tropes Categories
Lori Loughlin
as Kristy Thomas in The Babysitters Club (90s Adult Cast)
Jody Marken
as Final Girl in Characters Sorted by TV Tropes Categories
Rachel Miner
as Katie O'Shea in Carrie (1996)
Sienna Shaw
as Final Girl in Characters Sorted by TV Tropes Categories
Heidi Kozak
as 80s' in Which Actresses Should've Played Pam Miller in Various Decades?
Heather McComb
as 90s' in Which Actress Should've Played Heidi in Various Decades?