Suggestions by @cassiapalpatine

Assad Zaman

as Jonathan Sims in The Magnus Archives

Score: +1

Robert Pattinson

as Hermes in Mythology

Score: +1

Eiza González

as Circe in Mythology

Score: +1

Lily Collins

as Megara in Mythology

Score: +1

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as Heracles in Mythology

Score: +2

KJ Apa

as Paris in Mythology

Score: +1

Assad Zaman

as Dionysus in Mythology

Score: +2

Anthony Ramos

as Patroclus in Mythology

Score: +1

Jason Momoa

as Hector in Mythology

Score: +1

Lucas Till

as Achilles in Mythology

Score: +1

Paul Bullion

as Menelaus in Mythology

Score: +1

Caity Lotz

as Helen in Mythology

Score: +1

Morena Baccarin

as Penelope in Mythology

Score: +1

Richard Madden

as Odysseus in Mythology

Score: -1

Zendaya

as Eurydice in Mythology

Score: +1

Tom Holland

as Orpheus in Mythology

Score: +2

Johnny Depp

as Poseidon in Mythology

Score: +2

Zoë Kravitz

as Persephone in Mythology

Score: +1

Idris Elba

as Hades in Mythology

Score: +1

Emily Blunt

as Hera in Mythology

Score: +1