Suggestions by @carsonmcdade

Ian McKellen

as Anthony Clarke in Little Hope

Michael Caine

as The Curator in The Devil In Me

Jessie Buckley

as Kate Wilder in The Devil In Me

Kathy Bates

as Eliza in The Quarry

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Constance in The Quarry

David Harbour

as Bobby in The Quarry

Willem Dafoe

as Jebidiah in The Quarry

Bruce Campbell

as Travis in The Quarry

Matthew Morrison

as Jacob in The Quarry

Joe Keery

as Dylan in The Quarry

Shameik Moore

as Ryan in The Quarry

Madison Iseman

as Emma in The Quarry

Timothée Chalamet

as Nick in The Quarry

Jamie Chung

as Kaitlyn in The Quarry

Lili Reinhart

as Abigail in The Quarry

Tom Holland

as Max Brinly in The Quarry

Keanu Reeves

as Chris Hackett in The Quarry

Emma Roberts

as Laura in The Quarry

Emma Watson

as Laura in The Quarry

Sofia Carson

as Emily Davis in Until Dawn