Suggestions by @cameronholmes

Brian Cox

as Rupert Thorne in The Red Hood S2

Score: +1

Zahn McClarnon

as Deacon Blackfire in Red Robin S3

Score: +1

Mckenna Grace

as Secret in Red Robin S3

Score: +2

Jared Padalecki

as Harm in Red Robin S3

Score: +1

Jessie T. Usher

as Det. Ethan Bennett in The Bat-Family

Score: +1

Arden Cho

as Det. Ellen Yin in The Bat-Family

Score: +1

Dan Stevens

as Jimmy Gordan in The Bat-Family

Score: +1

Dan Steadman

as Jimmy Gordan in The Bat-Family

Score: +1

Julianne Moore

as Officer Sarah Essen Gordan in The Bat-Family

Score: +1

Jessie T. Usher

as Det. Bennett in GCPD: Gotham City Police Department

Score: +1

Arden Cho

as Det. Yin in GCPD: Gotham City Police Department

Score: +1

Julianne Moore

as Officer Sarah Essen Gordan in GCPD: Gotham City Police Department

Score: +1

Dan Stevens

as Jimmy Gordan in GCPD: Gotham City Police Department

Score: +1

Zoey Deutch

as Barbara Gordan in GCPD: Gotham City Police Department

Score: +2

Stephanie Beatriz

as Officer Montoya in GCPD: Gotham City Police Department

Score: +1

Michael Madsen

as Det. Bullock in GCPD: Gotham City Police Department

Score: +1

J.K. Simmons

as Commissioner Gordan in GCPD: Gotham City Police Department

Score: +1

Arden Cho

as Commissioner Yin in The Red Hood S2

Score: +2

Jessie T. Usher

as Det. Bennett in The Red Hood S2

Score: +1

Jesse Usher

as Det. Bennett in The Red Hood S2

Score: -1