Suggestions by @caitlinfrost

Drednaw

as Turtle/Tortoise in Fictional animals by species

Score: +2

Chewtle

as Turtle/Tortoise in Fictional animals by species

Score: +2

Turtonator

as Turtle/Tortoise in Fictional animals by species

Score: +2

Jumba Jookiba

as Carlos in Casting musicals...with Disney characters.

Score: +1

Pleakley

as Nikos in Casting musicals...with Disney characters.

Score: +1

Bagheera

as Munkustrap in Casting musicals...with Disney characters.

Score: +1

Kitty Lynxley

as Rumpleteazer in Casting musicals...with Disney characters.

Score: +1

Cattrick Lynxley

as Mungojerrie in Casting musicals...with Disney characters.

Score: +1

Cattrick Lynxley

as Mungojerrie and Rumpleteazer in Casting musicals...with Disney characters.

Score: +1

Milton Lynxley

as Macavity the Mystery Cat in Casting musicals...with Disney characters.

Score: +1

Maleficent

as The Wicked Witch of the West in Casting musicals...with Disney characters.

Score: +1

Jacob Marley

as Posthumous Character in Sort by Tropes

Score: +1

Lurantis

as Mantis in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Fomantis

as Mantis in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Jewel

as June Carter Cash in Actors by Historical Figures They've Played

Score: +1

Reese Witherspoon

as June Carter Cash in Actors by Historical Figures They've Played

Score: +1

Wicked (musical)

as The Museverse in Make Your Own Universe

Score: +1

Danny DeVito

as The Flying House in HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA - THE MOVIE!

Score: +1

Dan Backslide

as Edgar Balthazar in Disney Villains- Crossover Edition

Score: +1

Velma Von Tussle

as Mother Gothel in Disney Villains- Crossover Edition

Score: +1