Suggestions by @caillansilver
666 suggestions
Jim Carrey
as Colonel Mustard in Clue
Score: +1
Mike Faist
as Wadsworth in Clue
Score: +2
Caissie Levy
as Velma Von Tussle in Hairspray (story removed)
Score: +1
Mallory Bechtel
as Penny Lou Pingleton in Hairspray (story removed)
Score: +1
Mackenzie Kurtz
as Penny Lou Pingleton in Hairspray (story removed)
Score: -1
Dove Cameron
as Amber Von Tussle in Hairspray (story removed)
Score: +1
Lola Tung
as Fate 2 in Hadestown
Score: +1
Daveed Diggs
as Hermes in Hadestown
Score: +1
Colman Domingo
as Hades in Hadestown
Score: +1
Roman Griffin Davis
as Jack in Into the woods
Score: +1
Ariana Greenblatt
as Little red in Into the woods
Score: +1
Jorja Smith
as Repunzel in Into the woods
Score: +1
Jordan Fisher
as Prince Charming in Into the woods
Score: +1
Corey Hawkins
as Repunzel’s Prince in Into the woods
Score: +1
Nicole Sherzinger
as The Witch in Into the woods
Score: +1
Phillipa Soo
as The bakers wife in Into the woods
Score: +1
Philipa Soo
as The bakers wife in Into the woods
Score: -1
Aaron Tveit
as The Baker in Into the woods
Score: +1
Ariana Grande
as Cinderella in Into the woods
Score: +1
Elizabeth Olsen
as Natalie Wood in James
Score: +1