Suggestions by @caillansilver

Max Barskih

as Mischa Bachinski in Ride the Cyclone

Score: +1

Dove Cameron

as Ocean O'Connell Rosenberg in Ride the Cyclone

Score: -1

Luka Perta

as Noel Gruber in Ride the Cyclone

Score: +1

Jorja Smith

as Jane Doe/Penny Lamb in Ride the Cyclone

Score: -1

Remi Wolf

as Constance Blackwood in Ride the Cyclone

Score: +1

Conan Gray

as Jake in Zombie Prom

Score: +1

Joshua Bassett

as Josh in Zombie Prom

Score: +1

Jacob Collier

as Jonny Warner in Zombie Prom

Score: +1

Remi Wolf

as Candy in Zombie Prom

Score: +1

Bob the Drag Queen

as Eddie Flagrante in Zombie Prom

Score: +1

Sabrina Carpenter

as Coco in Zombie Prom

Score: +1

Lola Tung

as Ginger in Zombie Prom

Score: +1

Rachel Zegler

as Toffee in Zombie Prom

Score: +1

Jinkx Monsoon

as Delilah Strict in Zombie Prom

Score: +1

Jeremy Jordan

as Earl Hutcherson in Waitress Musical

Score: 0

Chris Olsen

as Ogie in Waitress Musical

Score: +1

Emmy Rossum

as Jenna Hunterson in Waitress Musical

Score: 0

Lola Tung

as Dawn in Waitress Musical

Score: +2

Danielle Brooks

as Becky in Waitress Musical

Score: 0

Troye Sivan

as Patrick in The view from upstairs

Score: +1