Suggestions by @cabanaclubproductions

S. C. Yearty

as Alex Jonas in The Haunted Mansion

Score: +1

S. C. Yearty

as Marvin Gaye in Mercy Mercy Me

Score: +1

S. C. Yearty

as Arthur Ashe in Ashe

Score: +1

Pharrell Williams

as Arthur Ashe in Ashe

Score: -2

S. C. Yearty

as Miles Morales in Spider-Man

Score: -12