Suggestions by @c_chizzle

Alicia Silverstone

as Jess in One Killer

Joey Lawrence

as Donny in One Killer

Jonathan Bennett

as Paul in One Killer

Arlen Escarpeta

as Jamal in One Killer

Sabrina Carpenter

as Emma in One Killer

Lucy Hale

as Michelle in One Killer

James Maslow

as Jake in One Killer

Andy Milonakis

as Frank in One Killer

Rory Culkin

as Bret Hart in An Era of Attitude!

Rob Mac

as Bryan in No Guys Allowed

Jake T. Austin

as Max in No Guys Allowed

Alan Tudyk

as Joey in No Guys Allowed

Kyle Harvey

as Kyle in No Guys Allowed

Joseph Gordon-Levitt

as Shawn in Total Drama

Keke Palmer

as Jasmine in Total Drama

Ashley Tisdale-French

as Dakota in Total Drama

Jaleel White

as Cameron in Total Drama

John Cena

as Brick in Total Drama

Anthony Anderson

as Beardo in Total Drama

Snooki

as Anne Maria in Total Drama