Suggestions by @burtonbatfan

Dennis Weaver

as Commissioner James Gordon in Batman Forever (1975)

Score: +3

David Niven

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman Forever (1975)

Score: +5

Robby Benson

as Dick Grason in Batman Forever (1975)

Score: +7

Teresa Graves

as Dr. Chase Meridian in Batman Forever (1975)

Score: 0

Robert Walker Jr.

as Edward Nygma in Batman Forever (1975)

Score: 0

John Saxon

as Harvey Dent in Batman Forever (1975)

Score: +1

James Brolin

as Bruce Wayne in Batman Forever (1975)

Score: +4

James Brolin

as Bruce Wayne in Batman & Robin (1977)

Score: +4

Dennis Cole

as Charles 'Chip' Shreck in Batman Returns (1972)

Score: +1

Linda Gaye Scott

as The Ice Princess in Batman Returns (1972)

Score: +1

Dennis Weaver

as Commissioner James Gordon in Batman Returns (1972)

Score: +1

David Niven

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman Returns (1972)

Score: +2

Barbara Bach

as Selina Kyle in Batman Returns (1972)

Score: +2

Sorrell Booke

as The Penguin in Batman Returns (1972)

Score: +2

James Brolin

as Bruce Wayne in Batman Returns (1972)

Score: +1

Kate Upton

as The Ice Princess in Batman Returns

Score: +2

Elizabeth Debicki

as Mrs. Cobblepot in Batman Returns

Score: +4

Toby Jones

as Mr. Cobblepot in Batman Returns

Score: +3

Alexander Ludwig

as Charles Shreck in Batman Returns

Score: +4

Alec Baldwin

as Max Shreck in Batman Returns

Score: +2