Suggestions by @brooklynbeck

Hugh Jackman

as Gavriel in Caraval

Bailee Madison

as Scarlett Dragna in Caraval

Taylor Zakhar Perez

as Julian Santos in Caraval

Jason Isaacs

as Marcello Dragna in Caraval

Tom Blyth

as Jacks in Caraval

Nicholas Galitzine

as Dante in Caraval

Sabrina Carpenter

as Tella Dragna in Caraval

Theo James

as Legend in Caraval

Taylor Zakhar Perez

as Julian in Caraval

Sabrina Carpenter

as Donatella in Caraval

Bailee Madison

as Scarlett in Caraval

Tom Blyth

as Grayson Hawthorne in The Inheritance Games

Thomasin McKenzie

as Dottie Epstein in Truly Devious

Austin Abrams

as Nate Fisher in Truly Devious

Louis Hynes

as Nate Fisher in Truly Devious

Froy Gutierrez

as Hayes Major in Truly Devious

Rudy Pankow

as Hayes Major in Truly Devious

Kiernan Shipka

as Stevie Bell in Truly Devious

Sadie Sink

as Emily Laughlin in The Inheritance Games

Madison Iseman

as Libby in The Inheritance Games