Suggestions by @brayy
649 suggestions
Kate Siegel
as Karen Hopple in American Horror Story Recast
Janelle James
as Dr. Donna Chambers in American Horror Story Recast
Damon Herriman
as Richard Ramirez in American Horror Story Recast
Eugene Lee Yang
as Troy Lord in American Horror Story Recast
Stockard Channing
as Io Preecher in American Horror Story Recast
John C. Reilly
as Benjamin Richter in American Horror Story Recast
Jacob Elordi
as Xavier Plympton in American Horror Story Recast
Patrick Schwarzenegger
as Trevor Kirchner in American Horror Story Recast
Alicia Silverstone
as Margaret Booth in American Horror Story Recast
Joe Manganiello
as John Henry Moore in American Horror Story Recast
John Leguizamo
as Ariel Augustus in American Horror Story Recast
Skyler Gisondo
as Jonas Shevoore in American Horror Story Recast
Kid Cudi
as Ray Powell in American Horror Story Recast
Kathy Najimy
as Miriam Meed in American Horror Story Recast
Chris Lowell
as Brock in American Horror Story Recast
Winston Duke
as Behold Chablis in American Horror Story Recast
Nick Robinson
as Timothy Campbell in American Horror Story Recast
Avantika
as Mallory in American Horror Story Recast
Avantika Akerkar
as Mallory in American Horror Story Recast
Hari Nef
as Coco St. Pierre Vanderbilt in American Horror Story Recast