Suggestions by @boomstick2000

Liam Neeson

as Dwight McCarthy in Sin City (1992)

Christian Slater

as Kevin in Sin City (1992)

Harrison Ford

as Detective John Hartigan in Sin City (1992)

Tyler Bates

as Composer in The New God's (2010)

Tony Todd

as Darkseid in The New God's (2010)

Robert Knepper

as Dessad in The New God's (2010)

Kevin Durand

as Kalibak in The New God's (2010)

Alan Rickman

as Steppenwolf in The New God's (2010)

Michael C. Hall

as Glorious Godfrey in The New God's (2010)

Lucy Lawless

as Stompa in The New God's (2010)

Jessica Chastain

as Mad Harriet in The New God's (2010)

Olivia Wilde

as Lashina in The New God's (2010)

Pam Ferris

as Granny Goodness in The New God's (2010)

Donald Sutherland

as Highfather in The New God's (2010)

Shia LaBeouf

as Lightray in The New God's (2010)

Doug Jones

as Forager in The New God's (2010)

Danny Woodburn

as Oberon in The New God's (2010)

Rhona Mitra

as Big Barda in The New God's (2010)

Cillian Murphy

as Mr Miracle in The New God's (2010)

Karl Urban

as Orion in The New God's (2010)