Suggestions by @boomstick2000

John Turturro

as Don Lino in Shark Tale (2022)

Chris Columbus

as Director in Jumanji (2005)

Lauren Graham

as Nora Shepherd in Jumanji (2005)

Laura Linney

as Carol Parrish in Jumanji (2005)

Cameron Diaz

as Sarah Whittle in Jumanji (2005)

Steve Carell

as Alan Parrish in Jumanji (2005)

Jack Black

as Alan Parrish in Jumanji (2005)

Jude Law

as Westley in The Princess Bride (1997)

Gary Oldman

as Top Dollar in The Crow 1994 Alternative Cast

Alfred Molina

as Smee in Hook (2001)

Alan Rickman

as Captain Hook in Hook (2001)

Dan Hedaya

as Perry White in Superman: The Movie (1998)

Tom Holland

as Marty Mikalski in The Cabin in the Woods (2022)

Justice Smith

as Holden McCrea in The Cabin in the Woods (2022)

Jacob Elordi

as Curt Vaughan in The Cabin in the Woods (2022)

Sydney Sweeney

as Jules Louden in The Cabin in the Woods (2022)

Maya Hawke

as Dana Polk in The Cabin in the Woods (2022)

Winona Ryder

as Marion Ravenwood in Indiana Jones Trilogy (2001-2009)

Winona Ryder

as Marion Ravenwood in Indiana Jones Trilogy (2001-2009)

Emily Blunt

as Evil-Lyn in The Masters of the Universe