Suggestions by @boomstick2000

Salma Hayek

as Cat Grant in Superman (2005)

Louise Fletcher

as Ma Kent in Superman (2005)

Topher Grace

as Jimmy Olsen in Superman (2005)

Orlando Jones

as Mister Terrific in Superman (2005)

Michael Chiklis

as Metamorpho in Superman (2005)

Jordana Brewster

as Hawkgirl in Superman (2005)

Bill Paxton

as Green Lantern in Superman (2005)

Daniel Craig

as Lex Luthor in Superman (2005)

Jennifer Garner

as Lois Lane in Superman (2005)

James Marsden

as Superman in Superman (2005)

Peter Stormare

as Egor Korshunov in Air Force One (1997)

Michael Douglas

as President James Marshall in Air Force One (1997)

J. T. Walsh

as Mayor Larry Vaughn in Jaws (1995)

Robin Williams

as Timon in The Lion King Duology (1994-1998)

Dan Aykroyd

as Pumbaa in The Lion King Duology (1994-1998)

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Adult Kiara in The Lion King Duology (1994-1998)

Eric Idle

as Zazu in The Lion King Duology (1994-1998)

Jennifer Connelly

as Adult Nala in The Lion King Duology (1994-1998)

Miko Hughes

as Young Simba in The Lion King Duology (1994-1998)

Charles Dance

as Scar in The Lion King Duology (1994-1998)