Suggestions by @bmarrow

Michael Reid MacKay

as The Mummy in Terrordrome 2 (2011)

Score: +1

King Baggot

as Dr. Henry Jekyll in Terrordrome 2 (2011)

Score: +1

Lon Chaney Jr.

as Kharis in Terrordrome 2 (2011)

Score: +1

Robert Z'Dar

as Matthew Cordell in The Multiversal Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Nick Castle

as Michael Myers in The Multiversal Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Kane Hodder

as Jason Voorhees in The Multiversal Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Conan Stevens

as Man-Thing in The Multiversal Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Angus Scrimm

as The Tall Man in The Multiversal Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Bill Skarsgård

as The Crow in The Multiversal Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Jeffery Combs

as Doctor Mordrid in The Multiversal Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Keanu Reeves

as Constantine in The Multiversal Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Ron Perlman

as Hellboy in The Multiversal Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Michael Jai White

as Spawn in The Multiversal Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Nicolas Cage

as Ghost Rider in The Multiversal Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Wesley Snipes

as Blade in The Multiversal Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Arnold Vosloo

as Darkman in The Multiversal Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Reggie Bannister

as Reggie in The Multiversal Midnight Sons

Score: +2

Bruce Campbell

as Ash Williams in The Multiversal Midnight Sons

Score: +2

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Doctor Strange in The Multiversal Midnight Sons

Score: +2

Danny Elfman

as Composer in Marvel Knights (Avengers 2000) (2009)

Score: +1