Suggestions by @bigbaddeath

Ian McKellen

as Dr. Martin Brenner in Stranger Things (1996-2005)

Score: +3

Freddie Prinze Jr.

as Steve Harrington in Stranger Things (1996-2005)

Score: 0

Jennifer Love Hewitt

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things (1996-2005)

Score: -1

Scarlett Johansson

as Max Mayfield in Stranger Things (1996-2005)

Score: -1

Joseph Mazzello

as Will Byers in Stranger Things (1996-2005)

Score: +3

Marcus T. Paulk

as Lucas Sinclair in Stranger Things (1996-2005)

Score: +3

Danny Tamberelli

as Dustin Henderson in Stranger Things (1996-2005)

Score: +3

Elijah Wood

as Mike Wheeler in Stranger Things (1996-2005)

Score: +3

Natalie Portman

as Eleven in Stranger Things (1996-2005)

Score: +4

Geena Davis

as Joyce Byers in Stranger Things (1996-2005)

Score: -1

Tom Selleck

as Jim Hopper in Stranger Things (1996-2005)

Score: +4

Kurt Russell

as Doc Hudson in Cars (2026)

Score: -2

Matthew McConaughey

as Mr. Wolf in The Bad Guys (2007-2010)

Score: +9

John Leguizamo

as Mr. Piranha in The Bad Guys (2007-2010)

Score: +9

Rashida Jones

as Tiffany Fluffit in The Bad Guys (2007-2010)

Score: +8

Allison Janney

as Chief Misty Luggins in The Bad Guys (2007-2010)

Score: +8

Anna Faris

as Pigtail in The Bad Guys (2007-2010)

Score: +8

Tina Fey

as Doom in The Bad Guys (2007-2010)

Score: +8

Queen Latifah

as Kitty Kat in The Bad Guys (2007-2010)

Score: +8

Brenda Song

as Ms. Tarantula in The Bad Guys (2007-2010)

Score: +7