Suggestions by @bifluidmax08

Lauren Patten

as Elizabeth Midford in What If It's Us? (Black Butler Fanfic)

Remy Zaken

as Amelia Frandins in What If It's Us? (Black Butler Fanfic)

Taron Egerton

as Grell Sutcliff in What If It's Us? (Black Butler Fanfic)

Bella Ramsey

as Joanne Harcourt in What If It's Us? (Black Butler Fanfic)

Bonnie Wright

as Duchess Alice Harcourt in What If It's Us? (Black Butler Fanfic)

Millie Bobby Brown

as Violet Delamir (Harcourt) in What If It's Us? (Black Butler Fanfic)

Rowan Blanchard

as Mila Harcourt in What If It's Us? (Black Butler Fanfic)

Jack Dylan Grazer

as Ciel Phantomhive in What If It's Us? (Black Butler Fanfic)

Julia Quinn

as Writer in What If It's Us? (Black Butler Fanfic)

Jeremy Jordan

as Vincent Phantomhive in What If It's Us? (Black Butler Fanfic)

Gideon Glick

as Cheslock in What If It's Us? (Black Butler Fanfic)

Aidan Gallagher

as Alois Trancy in What If It's Us? (Black Butler Fanfic)

Tim Burton

as Director in What If It's Us? (Black Butler Fanfic)

Andy Mientus

as Edward Midford in What If It's Us? (Black Butler Fanfic)