Suggestions by @berriessi

Henry Cavill

as Bruce Wayne in Batfam TV Show

+1-2Score: -1

Henry Cavill

as Bruce Wayne in The Batfamily vs. Gotham's Rogues

+1-1Score: 0

Jacob Elordi

as Dick Grayson in The Batfamily vs. Gotham's Rogues

+1-2Score: -1

Alexa Demie

as Cleo de Nile in Monster High

+3-6Score: -3

Ryan Reynolds

as Spider Man Noir in Spider-Man Into the Spider Verse Live Action

+1-3Score: -2