Suggestions by @bendle29
3,063 suggestions
Tara Strong
as Sally Williams in Creepypastas Characters.
Jeff Bennett
as Eyeless Jack in Creepypastas Characters.
Keith Silverstein
as X-Virus in Creepypastas Characters.
Sarah Anne Williams
as Zero in Creepypastas Characters.
Dave Wittenberg
as Candy Pop in Creepypastas Characters.
Alastair James
as Jason The Toymaker in Creepypastas Characters.
Jude Law
as The Puppeteer in Creepypastas Characters.
Dan Green
as The Puppeteer in Creepypastas Characters.
Alessandro Juliani
as Bloody Painter in Creepypastas Characters.
AJ Michalka
as Clockwork in Creepypastas Characters.
Alan Tudyk
as Skin-Taker in Creepypastas Characters.
Brock Baker
as Skin-Taker in Creepypastas Characters.
John Lithgow
as Skin-Taker in Creepypastas Characters.
Tim Curry
as Skin-Taker in Creepypastas Characters.
Jonathan Jones/Laphin Hyena
as Mr. Widemouth in Creepypastas Characters.
Gildart Jackson
as Seed-Eater in Creepypastas Characters.
Andrew Morgado
as The Rake in Creepypastas Characters.
Fred Tatasciore
as Smile Dog in Creepypastas Characters.
Steve Blum
as Laughing Jack in Creepypastas Characters.
Kevin Dorman
as Liu Woods in Creepypastas Characters.