Suggestions by @beabeacakesbeabeacakes

Will Smith

as Pope in Outer Banks but in the 90s

Score: +1

Paul Walker

as JJ in Outer Banks but in the 90s

Score: +1

Halle Berry

as Kiara/Kie in Outer Banks but in the 90s

Score: +2

Skeet Ulrich

as Rafe Cameron in Outer Banks but in the 90s

Score: +2