Suggestions by @ayeha

Daniel Day-Lewis

as Carter Burke in Aliens

Score: -1

Emily Blunt

as Ellen Ripley in Aliens

Score: +4

Benedict Cumberbatch

as 1st Officer Murdoch in Titanic

Score: +3

Kenneth Branagh

as Edward John Smith in Titanic

Score: +3

Ethan Suplee

as Tommy Ryan in Titanic

Score: -1

Logan Thompson

as Vic Criss in It (2007)

Score: -1

Logan Thompson

as Victor Criss in IT

Score: +12

Eric Bana

as Garrett Wilkinson in Mission Awesome

Score: +1

Nicholas Hamilton

as Zak Kowlazeski in Mission Awesome

Score: +2

Chris Evans

as Duke Darryl in Mission Awesome

Score: +1

Russell Crowe

as Jason Anderson in Deepwater Horizon

Score: 0

Gary Oldman

as Jimmy Harrell in Deepwater Horizon

Score: +1

John Goodman

as Mike Williams in Deepwater Horizon

Score: +1