Suggestions by @axis_004

Brendan Fraser

as Garfield Lynns in The Batgirl From Oak Cliff

Score: +1

Robert Downey Jr.

as James Gordon in The Batgirl From Oak Cliff

Score: -1

Adela Noriega

as Barbara Eileen in The Batgirl From Oak Cliff

Score: +1

Leslie Grace

as Barbara Gordon in The Batgirl From Oak Cliff

Score: +1

Adrián Uribe

as Ricardo Tapia in The Batgirl From Oak Cliff

Score: +1

Eugenio Derbez

as Bruno Diaz in The Batgirl From Oak Cliff

Score: +1

Adrien Brody

as Man-Bat in GCPD Season 3

Score: +1

Henry Winkler

as Ventriloquist in GCPD Season 3

Score: +1

Ashton Kutcher

as Killer Moth in GCPD Season 3

Score: +1

Aaron Paul

as Firefly in GCPD Season 3

Score: +1

Toby Jones

as Mad Hatter in GCPD Season 3

Score: +1

David Tennant

as The Riddler in GCPD Season 3

Score: +1

Toby Jones

as The Riddler in GCPD Season 3

Score: -1

Oscar Isaac

as Two-Face in GCPD Season 3

Score: +1

Cara Delevingne

as Poison Ivy in Batman: The Last Laugh

Score: +1

Dascha Polanco

as Reene Montoya in Batman: The Last Laugh

Score: +1

Dascha Polanco

as Reene Montoya in GCPD Season 2

Score: +1

Dascha Polanco

as Reene Montoya in GCPD Season 1

Score: +1

Bill Skarsgård

as The Joker in Batman: Madness Ascends

Score: +1

Bill Skarsgård

as The Joker in Batman: The Fallen Knight (TV miniseries)

Score: +1