Suggestions by @austenjane1813

Alexander Siddig

as Zeb Autry in Divine Rivals

Score: +2

SpongeBob in Real Life

as Boq in Wicked

Score: +1

Jeremy Allen White

as Tony Rodomovsky in The Huntress

Score: +1

Jordan Fisher

as Raoul, Vicomte de Changy in Phantom of the Opera

Score: +1

Corey Mylchreest

as Raoul, Vicomte de Changy in Phantom of the Opera

Score: +2

Corey Mylchreest

as Gabriel Lightwood in The Infernal Devices

Score: +1

Phil Dunster

as Forest Winnow in Divine Rivals

Score: -5

Daisy Head

as Elinor Little in Divine Rivals

Score: -2

Anthony Head

as Mr Kitt in Divine Rivals

Score: +1

Hannah Waddingham

as Helena Hammond in Divine Rivals

Score: -3

Hugh Grant

as Mr Kitt in Divine Rivals

Score: 0

Vanessa Redgrave

as Daisy Winnow in Divine Rivals

Score: +5

Lewis Tan

as Forest Winnow in Divine Rivals

Score: -6

Emily Mortimer

as Helena Hammond in Divine Rivals

Score: +2

Patrick Gibson

as Lieutenant Lark in Divine Rivals

Score: +4

Ncuti Gatwa

as Captain Speer in Divine Rivals

Score: +2

Julie Andrews

as Nan Kitt in Divine Rivals

Score: +4

Iain Glen

as Mr Kitt in Divine Rivals

Score: +3

Jessica Alexander

as Elinor Little in Divine Rivals

Score: +6

Edward Bluemel

as Forest Winnow in Divine Rivals

Score: -5