Suggestions by @angelbelladonna

Jeremy Allen White

as Elwood Dalton in Road House

Score: +1

Liam Hemsworth

as Elwood Dalton in Road House

Score: +2

Gaten Matarazzo

as Lexington in Gargoyles (Disney+ Live-Action Reboot)

Score: -3

Tom Holland

as Lexington in Gargoyles (Disney+ Live-Action Reboot)

Score: -3

Benedict Cumberbatch

as David Xanatos in Gargoyles (Disney+ Live-Action Reboot)

Score: -6

Dwayne Johnson

as Goliath in Gargoyles (Disney+ Live-Action Reboot)

Score: -9

Bobby Lashley

as Goliath in Gargoyles (Disney+ Live-Action Reboot)

Score: -1

Michael Rosenbaum

as David Xanatos in Gargoyles (Disney+ Live-Action Reboot)

Score: -2