Suggestions by @amyhoward

Naya Rivera

as Lea Carson in The Secret Bedroom

Grant Gustin

as Don Jacobs in The Secret Bedroom

Kiernan Shipka

as Winnie Foster in Tuck Everlasting

Ashley French

as Narrator in Tuck Everlasting (2012)

Bonnie Wright

as Winnie Foster in Tuck Everlasting (2012)

Grant Gustin

as Miles Tuck in Tuck Everlasting (2012)

Calum Worthy

as Todd in Goodnight Kiss/Goodnight Kiss 2

Josh Hutcherson

as Matt Daniels in Goodnight Kiss/Goodnight Kiss 2

Chord Overstreet

as Steve Barron in Broken Hearts

Dianna Agron

as Becka Norwood in The Best Friend

Grant Gustin

as Bill Planter in The Best Friend

Darren Criss

as Eric Fraser in The Best Friend

Lea Michele

as Lilah Brewer in The Best Friend

Bella Thorne

as Honey Perkins in The Best Friend

Christian Slater

as Jason Dean in Heathers but like kids

Max Adler

as Martin "Dumptruck" Dunnstock in Genderbent Heathers

Chord Overstreet

as Harry Chandler in Genderbent Heathers

Grant Gustin

as Jason "J.D." Dean in Heathers The Musical (Animated Adaptation)

Clark Gregg

as Paul Kelly in Heathers: The Musical (Animated)

Casey Cott

as Ram Sweeney in Heathers: The Musical (Animated)