Suggestions by @amyhoward
808 suggestions
Ross Lynch
as Luke Stone in Fear Street Cheerleaders
Nina Dobrev
as Caitlin Munroe in The Dare
Matthew Morrison
as Mr. Northwood in The Dare
Sophie Turner
as Margaret Rivers in The Dare
Kelli Berglund
as Johanna Wise in The Dare
Mateus Ward
as Dennis Arthur in The Dare
Amy Adams
as Mary Beth in Bad Moonlight
Dianna Agron
as Martha Powell in The Face
Bella Thorne
as Justine in The Face
Ian Somerhalder
as Aaron in The Face
Selena Gomez
as Natalie Erickson in Dead End
Betty White
as Grandma Carla in Switched
Bella Thorne
as Nicole Darwin in Switched
Kenton Duty
as Kent Borden in Switched
Peyton List
as Lucy Kramer in Switched
Mateus Ward
as Chris in College Weekend
Cole Sprouse
as Adam Messner in The Cheater
Nathaniel Buzolic
as Jon Davis in The Perfect Date
Idina Menzel
as Mrs. Nordstrom in 99 Fear Street: The House of Evil
Mateus Ward
as Brandt McCloy in 99 Fear Street: The House of Evil