Suggestions by @amazonprince

Carroll Baker

as Baba Yaga in DC Vertigo - The Books of Magic (1990)

Tori Amos

as Queen Titania in DC Vertigo - The Books of Magic (1990)

Julie Strain

as Madame Xanadu in DC Vertigo - The Books of Magic (1990)

Daniel Day-Lewis

as Mister E in DC Vertigo - The Books of Magic (1990)

Daniel Radcliffe

as Timothy Hunter in DC Vertigo - The Books of Magic (1990)

Bela Lugosi

as Doctor Fate in DC Vertigo - The Books of Magic (1990)

Vincent Price

as The Wizard in DC Vertigo - The Books of Magic (1990)

Max von Sydow

as The Phantom Stranger in DC Vertigo - The Books of Magic (1990)

Andrew Garfield

as Timothy Hunter in DC Vertigo - The Books of Magic (1990)

Ricardo Montez

as Doctor Occult in DC Vertigo - The Books of Magic (1990)

Humphrey Bogart

as Doctor Occult in DC Vertigo - The Books of Magic (1990)

Joseph Gordon-Levitt

as Timothy Hunter in DC Vertigo - The Books of Magic (1990)

Sheila Ferguson

as Bumblebee in The Other History of the DC Universe (1978)

Ray Vitte

as Mal Duncan in The Other History of the DC Universe (1978)

Rona Hartner

as Zatanna in DC Vertigo - The Books of Magic (1990)

Sting

as Constantine in DC Vertigo - The Books of Magic (1990)

Dick Durock

as Swamp Thing in DC Black Orchid (1987)

Sting

as Constantine in DC Black Orchid (1987)

Elizabeth Berkley

as Black Orchid in DC Black Orchid (1987)

John Williams

as Composer in Justice League of America 1990s