Suggestions by @all_about_atyd

Zoë Kravitz

as Dorcas Meadowes in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: +3

Bree Kish

as Lily Evans in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: -6

Charlie Oldman

as Sirius Black in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: +5

Tripp Bowers

as Sirius Black in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: -4

Timothée Chalamet

as Regulus Black in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: +8

Tom Holland

as Grant Chapman in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: -6

Thomas Brodie-Sangster

as Grant Chapman in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: -1

George MacKay

as Grant Chapman in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: +11

Tara Sutaria

as Yasmin Patil in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: +3

Basma Al Otaibi

as Yasmin Patil in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: -3

Mandip Gill

as Yasmin Patil in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: +7

Florence Pugh

as Marlene McKinnon in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: +7

Freya Mavor

as Marlene McKinnon in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: -3

Alicia Vikander

as Marlene McKinnon in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: +6

Zoë Kravitz

as Mary McDonald in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: -7

Skai Jackson

as Mary McDonald in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: -7

Madison Pettis

as Mary McDonald in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: -5

Zendaya

as Mary McDonald in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: -5

Tashi Rodriguez

as Mary McDonald in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: -1

Amandla Stenberg

as Mary McDonald in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*

Score: 0