Suggestions by @alamosimpson

John Cusack

as Lt. Mike Carter in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 4x6- Death Ship

Kevin Costner

as Capt. Paul Ross in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 4x6- Death Ship

Will Friedle

as Thompson in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x37 - The Changing of The Guard

Chris O'Donnell

as Dickie Weiss in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x37 - The Changing of The Guard

Matt Damon

as Artie Beechcroft in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x37 - The Changing of The Guard

William Daniels

as Professor Ellis Fowler in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x37 - The Changing of The Guard

Jimmy Smits

as Doctor in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x32 - The Gift

Mario López

as Mr. Williams in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x32 - The Gift

Steven Spielberg

as Director in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x35 - I Sing the Body Electric

Steven Spielberg

as Producer in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x35 - I Sing the Body Electric

Jodie Sweetin

as Anne in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x35 - I Sing the Body Electric

Stephen Root

as Salesman in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x35 - I Sing the Body Electric

Bebe Neuwirth

as Nedra in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x35 - I Sing the Body Electric

Melissa Joan Hart

as Karen (Age 18) in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x35 - I Sing the Body Electric

Madeline Zima

as Karen in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x35 - I Sing the Body Electric

Andrew Lawrence

as Tom in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x35 - I Sing the Body Electric

Joey Lawrence

as Tom (Age 20) in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x35 - I Sing the Body Electric

Drew Barrymore

as Anne (Age 21) in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x35 - I Sing the Body Electric

Rosemary Harris

as Grandma in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x35 - I Sing the Body Electric

William Russ

as Mr. Rogers in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x35 - I Sing the Body Electric