Suggestions by @agnesflame

Will Tudor

as James Smith in The Dozen

Score: +2

Sam Claflin

as Paul McDonald in The Dozen

Score: +2

Bae Doona

as Jung Min in The Dozen

Score: +2

Matthew Gray Gubler

as Dr. Aaron Mist in The Dozen

Score: +2

Michael Malarkey

as Romeo Nicoletti in The Dozen

Score: +3

Shemar Moore

as Jesse Reese in The Dozen

Score: +3

Jesse Eisenberg

as David Geller in The Dozen

Score: +2

Naomi Scott

as Zita Anderson in The Dozen

Score: +2

Lesley Nicol

as Prue in The Dozen

Score: +2

Paige Spara

as Dr. Ramona Joyce in The Dozen

Score: +2

Mandy Moore

as Carina Sullivan in The Dozen

Score: +2

Shane West

as General Brenton Joyce in The Dozen

Score: +2

Sarah Gadon

as Lilith Decay in The Dozen

Score: +2

Gugu Mbatha-Raw

as Eve Grow in The Dozen

Score: +2

Ian Somerhalder

as Paul Connolly in The Dozen

Score: +2

Sam Witwer

as Chester Capa in The Dozen

Score: +2

Alexander Skarsgård

as Jason Humble in The Dozen

Score: +2

Eiza González

as Salma Cortez in The Dozen

Score: +2

Kat Graham

as Sasha Terra in The Dozen

Score: +2

Kaya Scodelario

as Sarah Wave in The Dozen

Score: +2