Suggestions by @accaffrey

Nick Offerman

as Sean in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Emma Stone

as Ella in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Jennifer Lawrence

as Jameson in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

David Harbour

as Ben in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Luis Guzmán

as Bryan in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Kate McKinnon

as Kim in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Jessie Buckley

as Madi in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Martin Starr

as Peter in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Ben Schwartz

as James in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Alex Joseph Grayson

as Amari in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Michelle Rodriguez

as Nex in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Michelle Rodríguez

as Nex in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Rachel McAdams

as Reagan in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Elisabeth Moss

as Alex in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Charles Melton

as Silas in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Mikey Madison

as Aaliyah in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Elle Fanning

as Isabelle in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Alan Ritchson

as Joe in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Oscar Isaac

as Jayden in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1

Macaulay Culkin

as Logan in Murder at Caffrey Manor(story private)

Score: +1