Suggestions by @abbygrey
45 suggestions
Blair Underwood
as Demetrius in Stardew Valley
Anson Mount
as Kent in Stardew Valley
Annie Murphy
as Penny in Stardew Valley
Zoë Kravitz
as Maru in Stardew Valley
Amandla Stenberg
as Maru in Stardew Valley
Sydney Sweeney
as Haley in Stardew Valley
Alicia Witt
as Robin in Stardew Valley
Ross Butler
as Alex in Stardew Valley
Josh Hutcherson
as Sam in Stardew Valley
Zac Efron
as Alex in Stardew Valley
Evan Peters
as Shane in Stardew Valley
Noah Centineo
as Alex in Stardew Valley
Aaron Taylor-Johnson
as Harvey in Stardew Valley
Jonas Bloquet
as Elliot in Stardew Valley
Juliette Lewis
as Olivia in One of Us is Dead
Natalie Dormer
as Olivia in One of Us is Dead
Krysten Ritter
as Olivia in One of Us is Dead
Katherine Heigl
as Olivia in One of Us is Dead
Tom Hardy
as Dean in One of Us is Dead
Jamie Pressly
as Shannon in One of Us is Dead