Suggestions by @24601
2,495 suggestions
Antony Starr
as Finrod in Beren and Luthien
Colin O'Donoghue
as Celebrimbor in Beren and Luthien
Saoirse Ronan
as Galadriel in Beren and Luthien
Garrett Hedlund
as Imrahil in The Nameless King
Blake Lively
as Finduilas in The Nameless King
Michelle Williams
as Morwen in The Nameless King
Andrew Lincoln
as Arathorn in The Nameless King
Cate Blanchett
as Galadriel in The Nameless King
Linda Hamilton
as Gilraen 40-100 in The Nameless King
Michael Shannon
as Denethor 30-50 in The Nameless King
Viggo Mortensen
as Aragorn 50-87 in The Nameless King
Craig Parker
as Haldir in The Nameless King
Christopher Meloni
as Halbarad in The Nameless King
Ian Holm
as Bilbo Baggins in The Nameless King
David Harbour
as Grimbeorn in The Nameless King
Andy Serkis
as Gollum in The Nameless King
Aaron Ashmore
as Elrohir in The Nameless King
Shawn Ashmore
as Elladan in The Nameless King
Marton Csokas
as Celeborn in The Nameless King
Antony Starr
as Glorfindel in The Nameless King